Annual Academic Program Report

The Annual Academic Program Report (AAPR) was developed in response to the request of the Academic Affairs, Student Affairs and Personnel Committee at the November 2024 meeting for an annual update on a small set of metrics about each academic degree program at NIU. This annual report aligns with our commitment to being data-informed and increasing data accessibility across campus.

NIU is committed to using the AAPR to implement a collaborative, transparent process that supports thoughtful decision making, informed conversations and responsible stewardship of institutional resources to support student success, academic program quality and the university's mission.

VIEW THE ANNUAL ACADEMIC PROGRAM REPORT (DOCX)

AAPR Process

Regular review of the enrollment health and overall viability of academic programs is an important component of responsible academic planning and stewardship. This approach is important in both challenging and good times, but it is particularly important during periods of changing fiscal and enrollment conditions when the university needs to be able to respond quickly to invest in areas of evolving student interests, workforce needs and market demands.

In some cases, stewardship of the university's academic program portfolio may require sunsetting a low-enrolled and low-producing program to support the long-term health of other programs or to invest in new programs that strengthen NIU. In other cases, a program may benefit from strategic changes that position it for future growth and success, such as converting it to a minor, combining two or more smaller degree programs into a higher-demand interdisciplinary program, revitalizing the program through intentional redesign, or reducing curricular complexity to strengthen student access and program vitality.

When concerns arise about a program's viability, the AAPR process will engage college leadership, department and school leaders, program faculty and other stakeholders in identifying creative and realistic strategies to strengthen the program whenever possible. When program sunsetting must be considered, early identification will provide time for thoughtful discussion, planning, and efforts to minimize impacts on students, faculty and staff.

While enrollment trends are an important indicator of program health, they are only one factor in evaluating a program's overall performance and viability. Decision making must be informed by multiple sources of quantitative and qualitative data, including financial sustainability, student outcomes, workforce and market demand, alignment with the university's mission and strategic priorities, and other relevant considerations.

Guiding Principles for the AAPR Process

  • Stewardship: Careful stewardship of financial, academic and other institutional resources to support academic program quality and student success.
  • Transparency: Clear reporting of program enrollment health through university leadership and shared governance bodies.
  • Accountability: Use of reliable data and clearly defined measures, including enrollment and graduation rates.
  • Reliability: A consistent process with clear responsibilities, expectations and timelines.
  • Support: Access to data, tools, resources and assistance to inform decisions and strengthen the university’s academic program portfolio.
  • Process Improvement: Annual review of process implementation will be conducted in collaboration with APC and the Faculty Senate Steering Committee to identify opportunities for process improvement.

Program Categories

The distinction between Programs Approaching Concern and Programs of Concern is intended to support proactive stewardship of the academic portfolio, encourage early intervention and promote collaboration among departments/schools, colleges and the Provost's Office to support program vitality and student success.

Programs of Concern

The Provost’s Office will provide a draft list of Programs of Concern for a specific college to the dean of that college to review and provide input on whether they recommend that any program be removed from the list because they are already addressing challenges by taking specific and significant steps that are documented. After receiving this input, the Provost’s Office will finalize the list of Programs of Concern.

Programs with enrollment and graduation metrics that fall below established thresholds in Figure 1 will participate in a structured review process and prepare a written action plan that is co-developed by faculty and department chairs/school directors, reviewed by the dean including their input and recommendation, and submitted to the Provost's Office. This will be coordinated with any applicable requirements for the IBHE Academic Program Efficiency and Effectiveness Report (APEER.)

Figure 1: Metrics for Programs of Concern, 3-year Average
Metric Bachelor’s Degrees Master’s Degrees Doctoral Degrees
Enrollment 45 12 12
Degrees 10 6 3

Programs Approaching Concern

The Provost’s Office will provide a draft list of Programs Approaching Concern for a specific college to the dean of that college to review and provide input on whether they recommend that any program be removed from the list because they are already addressing challenges by taking specific steps. After receiving this input, the Provost’s Office will finalize the list of Programs Approaching Concern.

Programs with enrollment and graduation metrics that are near, but above, established thresholds in Figure 1 will be required to respond to a set of questions. The responses will be co-developed by faculty and department chairs/school directors, reviewed by the dean including their input and recommendation, and submitted to the Provost's Office. The thresholds for programs defined as approaching concern are provided in Figure 2.

Figure 2: Metrics for Programs Approaching Concern, 3-year Average
Metric Bachelor’s Degrees Master’s Degrees Doctoral Degrees
Enrollment 65 16 18
Degrees 20 7 4

Annual Process and Timeline

Fall Semester (October-November): AAPR Reporting and Communication

  • Academic Planning Council (APC) will review and finalize report at October meeting/s.
  • Provide AAPR to Faculty Senate at November meeting.
  • Present AAPR to Board of Trustees (BoT) at November meeting.
  • Share AAPR with Baccalaureate Council (BC,) Graduate Council (GC) and APC at regularly scheduled meetings as informational items.
  • Provide follow-up updates on prior AAPR outcomes alongside new data to BC, GC, deans, Faculty Senate and BoT.

Late Fall (Late November-Early December): Provost Notification and Expectations

  • Provost issues a formal memo to each dean identifying Programs of Concern and Programs Approaching Concern.
  • Deans begin meaningful consultation with chairs or directors, program faculty and appropriate department, school and college governance bodies.

Winter/Spring (December-April): College Review, Response and Provost Determination

  • Following notification from the provost, the dean will engage the chair or director, program faculty and appropriate college and department or school governance bodies in reviewing the program's data and developing the required response.
  • The dean will review the response and offer their input and recommendation.
  • The response requirements, review process and possible outcomes differ for Programs of Concern and Programs Approaching Concern, as described below.

Programs of Concern

The Provost's Office will provide the dean with a standard data package with enrollment and degree-production trends, recruitment and admissions pipeline data, student progression and completion indicators, course enrollment information, program resource and cost data, labor-market information, and relevant comparisons with peer or competitor programs.

The dean will charge the department chair or school director, program faculty and appropriate governance bodies to review the provided data and other available evidence, including qualitative local program data, and develop a written action plan recommending one of the following pathways: revitalization, reorganization or consolidation, or sunsetting. The group should also consult with EMMC and the college’s director of marketing and communication as they consider program awareness, marketing needs and costs. The action plan must present evidence and rationale supporting the recommendation, identify implementation responsibilities and resource requirements, and establish measurable outcomes and timelines. The group will present the action plan to the dean for their review, comment and recommendation.

The dean will submit the written action plan, including their input, to the Provost's Office by April 1. A provost-appointed review group (see Appendix A for membership) will evaluate the plan and may request additional information or consultation with the dean, chair or director, and program faculty. The group will either accept the recommendation or make an alternate recommendation. Following that review, the provost will communicate the group’s determination, any required revisions or actions, the approved monitoring period and performance expectations, and the date of the next review.

Written Action Plan Questions

  • Based on enrollment, student progression and completion, degree production, total program resources and costs, workforce demand, competitive position, alignment with institutional priorities, and other program-specific relevant quantitative and qualitative indicators, what evidence supports revitalizing, reorganizing/consolidating, or sunsetting the program?
  • Following consultation with program faculty and appropriate department or school and college governance bodies, which option does the college recommend: revitalization, reorganization/consolidation, or sunsetting? Explain the rationale, summarize the consultation process and identify any alternatives considered.
  • Based on the recommendation, respond to the appropriate prompt below:
    • If revitalization is recommended, what specific actions will be taken, who will be responsible, what resources will be required and on what timeline, and what measurable outcomes must be achieved by the established review date to demonstrate success? Identify interim milestones and the action that will occur if the program does not meet the approved targets.
    • If reorganization/consolidation is recommended, what specific actions will be taken, who will be responsible, what resources will be required and on what timeline, and what measurable outcomes must be achieved within the established timeline to demonstrate success? Identify interim milestones and the action that will occur if the approved targets are not achieved.
    • If sunsetting is recommended, describe the proposed timeline and the considerations that must be addressed in the implementation and teach-out plan. Address current and prospective students, communication and advising, course availability, accreditation or regulatory requirements, records, related programs, faculty and staff implications, and required curricular and governance approvals. Faculty and staff implications must be addressed in accordance with applicable university policies and collective bargaining agreements.
  • What college-level or institutional resources, approvals or policy decisions are necessary to implement the recommendation? Identify which commitments have been confirmed and which remain subject to approval.

Possible Outcomes for Programs of Concern

Following review of the written action plan, the provost review group will make one of the following determinations:

  • Proceed with an approved revitalization plan and remain designated Program of Concern during a defined monitoring period, with specified performance indicators, interim milestones and a scheduled review date.
  • Proceed with an approved reorganization or consolidation plan and remain designated Program of Concern until the approved curricular, organizational and governance actions have been completed and reviewed.
  • Begin the formal program sunsetting process, including development of an implementation and teach-out plan and completion of all required curricular, governance, accreditation, contractual and regulatory steps.
  • Revise and resubmit the action plan when the submitted evidence, consultation, proposed actions, resource commitments or measures of success are not sufficient to support a determination.

At the conclusion of an approved monitoring period, be removed from Program of Concern status if the program has met the established performance expectations and the provost-appointed review group determines that continued monitoring under this process is no longer necessary.

Programs Approaching Concern

The Provost's Office will provide the dean with a standard data package with enrollment and degree-production trends, recruitment and admissions pipeline data, student progression and completion indicators, course enrollment information, program resource and cost data, labor-market information, and relevant comparisons with peer or competitor programs.

The dean will charge the department chair or school director, program faculty and appropriate governance bodies to review the data and prepare a concise response and one-year improvement plan addressing the questions below. The group should consult with EMMC and the college’s director of marketing and communication as they consider program awareness, marketing needs and costs. The submission must identify the quantitative and qualitative evidence considered, proposed actions, responsible parties, expected outcomes and measures of progress. The total response and one-year improvement plan should not exceed five single-spaced pages, excluding optional supporting appendices. The group will present the response to the dean for their review, comment and recommendation.

The dean will submit the complete response and one-year improvement plan to the Provost's Office by April 1. A provost-appointed review group will evaluate the submission and may request additional information or consultation with the dean, department chair or school director, and program faculty. Following that review, the provost will communicate the program's designation, required actions, monitoring expectations, performance indicators and next review date.

Response and One-year Improvement Plan Questions

  • What factors appear to be contributing to the program's declining or stagnant enrollment and degree-production trends? Cite the quantitative and qualitative evidence supporting this assessment, including, as applicable, student demand, recruitment and admissions pipelines, retention and completion patterns, competitor programs, delivery modality and market conditions.
  • How well does the program's curriculum and delivery model align with current and emerging student interests, workforce and societal needs, disciplinary developments and pedagogical innovations? Identify any specific opportunities to update, reposition or enhance the program.
  • What actions can be initiated within one academic year to improve enrollment, student progression and graduation, and overall program vitality? For each action, identify the responsible party, implementation timeline, expected outcome, measure of success and institutional and/or college level resources needed.
  • What opportunities exist to improve program effectiveness or efficiency through curricular or organizational redesign, such as reducing curricular complexity, sharing courses, revising delivery models, strengthening interdisciplinary collaboration, or consolidating or sunsetting low-enrolled certificates, minors, concentrations, specializations or sub-plans? Describe the anticipated academic, student and resource opportunities and benefits.
  • What specific indicators and milestones should be reviewed at the end of the monitoring period to determine whether the program has demonstrated sufficient progress, requires continued monitoring or should be designated Program of Concern?

Possible Outcomes for Programs Approaching Concern

Following review of the submitted response and one-year improvement plan, the provost-appointed review group will make one of the following determinations.

  • Be removed from the monitoring list because the evidence demonstrates sufficient program health, improvement or other circumstances that do not warrant continued monitoring.
  • Continue with the Approaching Concern designation for an additional review cycle and implement an approved one-year improvement plan with specified indicators, milestones and a next review date.
  • Be designated Program of Concern and be required to submit a formal action plan according to the related process and timeline.

Spring (April): Institutional Reporting

Dean submissions and any available provost follow-up shared with BC and GC as informational items.

Following Academic Year (September-December): Curricular Action and Implementation

  • Approved program actions, such as sunsetting, reorganizations or revisions, proceed through BC and GC governance review as applicable.
  • Final decisions are implemented in the subsequent academic year according to approved timelines and applicable governance, accreditation, regulatory, policy and collective bargaining requirements.

Review Group Membership

  • Provost
  • Vice Provost for Academic Affairs
  • Vice Provost for Faculty Affairs (Chair of BC)
  • Vice Provost for Academic Innovation and Lifelong Learning
  • Dean of the Graduate School (Chair of GC)
  • Associate Vice President for Facilities and Resources
  • Assistant Vice Provost for Accreditation, Assessment and Evaluation
  • University Registrar, Director of Registration and Records
  • Executive Director for Institutional Research and Analytics
  • Faculty Senate President, Executive Secretary of University Council
  • Faculty Senate Steering Committee Appointee
  • Faculty Senate Steering Committee Appointee

Contact

Office of Executive Vice President and Provost
Altgeld Hall 215
815-753-9400
815-753-0701 (fax)
provost@niu.edu