| Year | Recipient | |
| 1995 | Howard & Milly Eychaner | |
| 1996 | Carl Schmidt, Alumnus Guy Maita, Alumnus Steve Berg, Alumnus Dennis McMullen (awarded posthumously) | |
| Faculty/Staff/Alumni Category |
Student Category | |
| 1997 | Norden Gilbert (Staff) | Sara Gray |
| 1998 | Margie Cook (Staff) | Jeanne Meyer |
| 1999 | Cordelia Parham (Alumna) | Mike Grandys |
| 2000 | Darsha Primich (Staff) | Adam Loredo |
| 2001 | Charles Schumann (Staff) | Rod Moore |
| 2002 | Rev. Rita Root (Staff) | Mary Shelden |
| 2003 | Gary Judd (Alumnus) | Louise Steeves |
| 2004 | Robert B. Ridinger (Faculty) | Karen Frost |
| 2005 | Diana L. Swanson (Faculty) | Wayne Wilkinson |
| 2006 | Victoria Graff (Alumna) | Kristen Scheurich |
| 2007 | Patricia Ridge (Faculty) | Andrea Drott |
| 2008 | Amy Levin (Faculty) | Scott Pickett |