DEPARTMENT OF POLITICAL SCIENCE
Political Science 150HP-1 Democracy in
Professor Gary D. Glenn Fall 2004
Office: Zu 307 Office Hours: MTWTH
Phone: 753-1091 11-11:45 am and by E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org appointment
Teaching Assistant: Michael Killoran
WHAT THIS COURSE IS
POLS 150 Democracy in America studies American political and social institutions primarily through the political thought, writings and speeches of three categories of people: 1)the nation's founders and the framers of the Declaration of Independence and the U.S. Constitution whose work structures the political controversies reappearing through subsequent generations; 2) office-holders who bore responsibility for dealing with these controversies and who both changed and preserved constitutional institutions and democratic thought and practice; and 3) influential non-office holders whose thought helped shape public opinion, social change and law and whose thought provided insight into both the goodness and badness of American democracy. Among the latter, Tocqueville's commentary, still (160 years after its publication) commonly regarded as the best ever written, gives this course its name and spirit.
WHY A CONSTITUTIONAL AND DEMOCRATIC FOCUS?
Emphasis is placed on the Constitution because, as the central legitimating symbol of American political life, citizens need to understand how it frames political controversy and how it influences political and social change. To that end, we will study important debates concerning both democratic institutions and the meaning of liberty and equality from the Founding until now. Such debates include whether we needed a national government and how the framers thought it could be kept from being oppressive; disputes about what political/economic conditions make American democracy possible; successive waves of controversies about whether the suffrage (voting rights) should be expanded; about whether the Founder's Constitution was democratic; about whether it was a slave or a free Constitution; about whether it recognized the humanity of the Negro, as African-Americans were then called; about whether the national government should regulate the economy and provide welfare; disputes about what democratic representation is; whether separation of powers prevents democracy or makes it possible; whether religion is an indispensable political institution or a persistent political problem; what makes one a citizen; what law-abidingness means and whether it is or is not a duty; and the relation of women to democratic government and society.
The persistent and over-arching theme of the class will be the disputed question "what is democracy"? In keeping with it's disputed nature, we will study a range of opposing answers. Considerable attention will be given to the perennial dispute about whether democracy, in the most humanly relevant and ennobling sense, is possible primarily through local institutions (as maintained in the American political tradition by the anti-Federalists and Tocqueville); or whether it is possible primarily through national institutions (as maintained generally by the Progressives, the New Deal, and the Great Society). This dispute turns on whether democracy is understood to involve (or be) primarily "self government" in that oneself and ones neighbors are primarily responsible for solving the day to day problems of living together (as the Jeffersonian tradition down to the Republican contract with America maintains); or whether democracy is understood to involve (or be) a greater degree of national-level government to regulate the nations economy in order to promote “economic democracy” and secure rights (as the Hamiltonian tradition down to modern “civil liberties” and “civil rights” maintains).
Both this over-arching theme and the nature of the readings present a distinctive approach to American democracy and government. The approach is historical, cultural, and philosophic, particularly emphasizing the mutual interdependence of governmental and social institutions. It is further distinguished by it's purpose which (unlike POLS 100) is not specifically to introduce students to the sub-field of American politics, or even to the political science major\minor (although it does that). It is aimed at all students whether or not they enter the course intending further study of political science. It's aim is deepening citizen's understanding and awareness of, persistent issues, arguments, and themes of American democracy's development.
All students are required to purchase their own copy of each of the following. They are available in both bookstores although Village Commons has more of #1.
2. Alexis de Tocqueville, Democracy in America. NY: Harper Collins Publishers, 1969 (originally published 1833).
3. Peter Lawler and Robert Schaefer eds. American Political Rhetoric 4th ed. (Rowman & Littlefield, 2001).
is liberal education and how does the study of Democracy in
Horace Mann, "Go Forth and Teach," July 4, 1842, in Reading Packet (RP) p. 173-174.
Martin Luther King, "The Purpose of Education," 1948, in RP, pp. 175-176.
I. What is American democracy? (How American ideas of democracy have both changed and stayed the same over time.)
A. Democracy in
The Declaration of
C. At the Founding: How the Founders distinguished between two kinds of “popular governments”: "democracy" and "republic." The problem of “faction” in “popular governments” and the Founders’ solution. Federalist Papers (1787-88) #10 in Lawler, pp. 15-21; #39, in Lawler, pp. 45-49. #14 in RP, p. 161. #63 in RP, p. 60-61.
D. Jeffersonian Democracy. Thomas Jefferson, Agriculture vs. manufacturing as ways of social life (1782), RP, pp. 161-162. First and Second Inaugural Addresses (1801, 1805) in RP, pp. 3-11. “On Citizenship" in RP, pp. 33-35.
E. Tocquevillian Democracy
1.Equality of conditions. DA "Author's Introduction" pp. 9-12.
2. Majority Rule. DA, "The Principle of
the Sovereignty of the People in
9/2 NO CLASS
9/7 QUIZ ONE
Majority Rule continued.
Omnipotence of the Majority in the
4. Rights. DA, “The Idea of Rights in the
F. Slavery and Democracy
1. Thomas Jefferson, Notes on the State of
2. William Lloyd Garrison, (1843) in RP p.11.
9/9-9/14 (QUIZ TWO on 9/14)
3. Frederick Douglass, speech
July Fourth for the Negro" in RP pp. 12-24.
4. Abraham Lincoln, "Address Delivered at the Dedication of the Cemetery at
G. Economic Democracy: The Progressives, the New Deal, and the Great Society
1. Theodore Roosevelt, "Two Noteworthy Books on Democracy," (1914) in RP,
9/16- 9/21 (QUIZ THREE on 9/21)
2. Franklin D. Roosevelt, "Commonwealth Club Campaign Speech," (1932)
Lawler pp. 174-82.
3. Franklin D. Roosevelt, "Message on the State of the
of Rights") (1944) in RP pp. 28-29.
4. Lyndon Johnson, "The Great Society" (1964) in Lawler pp. 193-95.
H. Civil Liberties Democracy
I. Civil Rights Democracy
Martin Luther King, "I Have a Dream" speech (1963) in RP pp. 30-33.
II. What political institutions enable American democracy to exist?
A. Voting: If “everyone” must have a right to vote in order to be a democracy,
1.Who did the original Constitution provide could vote? and for what offices? The
Constitution, For Congress: Art. I, Sec. 2, Cl. and Sec. 3, Cl. 1 in Lawler pp. 361.
For President: Art. II, Sec. 1, Cl. 2, Lawler p. 367; The Supreme Court? Sec. 2,
Lawler p. 369.
2. What are voting and elections for? How important did the Founders think the
right to vote is? Federalist Paper #52, in RP p. 38-39.
3. Who should have a right to vote? Federalist Papers #39 in Lawler pp. 45-46
9/28 QUIZ FOUR
4. What is "universal suffrage"?
b) DA, "Universal Suffrage" pp. 58-60 [esp. 59 bottom to 60 top], 196, 240.
5. Voting and Equality (of social conditions) and voting. DA, pp. 50-57, 503-06.
a) Extending the right to vote to women.
1) The argument from rights.
in RP pp. 44-47.
2) The argument from practical considerations.
Jane Addams, "Why Women Should Vote," (1910), in RP pp. 47-49.
3) Is voting a right of democratic citizenship?
Minor vs. Happersett (1875), in RP pp. 49-52.
in Lawler, p. 375, 378
10/5 QUIZ FIVE
b) Extending the right to vote to blacks.
2) Lyndon Johnson, “Address on Voting Rights” (1965), in RP pp. 52-58.
c) Extending the right to vote to 18 year olds.
6. Are any principled limits on the right to vote consistent with democracy,
in terms either of rights or of practice?
a) DA, pp. 197-203.
b) “The Motor-voter Act” (1994) Carol Moseley-Braun in RP pp.59-60.
PAPER ASSIGNED. Due 10/19.
7. Who/what should voters have a right to vote for (directly)?
a) The Constitution's answer: they should be able to vote for their representatives, but not directly for laws. and RP pp. 60-61.
1)Why was the Senate originally selected by state legislatures and why was that changed by the 17th Amendment? Federalist Papers #63, Lawler pp.84-86.
2) Why is the President elected
through the "Electoral College" rather than through "direct
3) Why is the Supreme Court appointed rather than elected? Federalist Papers
#78, Lawler, pp. 108-09, 112-13.
b) The Progressive's: voters should be able to legislate directly (initiative
& referendum) because representation has failed.
1) Theodore Roosevelt, “The Heirs of Abraham Lincoln” (1913) in RP pp 154-160
2) Theodore Roosevelt, “The Recall of Judicial Decisions” (1912) in RP pp.61-68.
Important Terms: fixed terms of office, recall, initiative, referendum, "terms limits"
10/12 c. Constitutionally who elects which federal offices?.
The Constitution, Art. I, Sec. 2, Cl. 2 and Sec. 3, Cl. 3. Art. II, Sec. 1, Cl. 3 & 5,
in Lawler pp. 361-62, 367-68.
B. Representation, political parties and interest groups
1.The Founders' Concern: the danger of "faction" and how representation is
supposed to mitigate it
Federalist Papers #10 in Lawler pp. 18-21 (read only the second half of #10);
#57, pp.79-81; #71, pp. 87-88; #52 in RP pp. 38-39.
2. Tocqueville on democratic representation. DA, p. 173.
3. The distinction between "great parties" and "small parties". DA, 174-79.
C. Separation of Powers
1. What is separation of powers and why is it necessary? Federalist Papers #47
in Lawler pp.21-27.
2. What is separation of powers supposed to do?
a. To secure liberty and protect us from tyranny.
Federalist Papers #48, #51, #71 in Lawler pp. 27-31, 34-36, 87-88.
10/19 PAPERS DUE
RECOMMEND STUDY GROUPS TO PREPARE FOR EXAM 10/30.
b. To make possible an energetic executive "independent" of the legislature.
1) Federalist Papers #37, in RP pp. 90-92 (combining stability and energy).
2) Federalist Papers #70 in Lawler 86-87.
3) Foreign Affairs. DA, pp. 226-30.
c. To make possible an independent judiciary to enforce the Constitution and laws.
1) Federalist Papers #78 in Lawler pp. 108-14.
2) Thomas Jefferson "Against Judicial Review"(1815), RP pp. 92-93.
10/21 PAPERS REQUIRING REVISION RETURNED TODAY
D. Federalism: What is it and why do we have it?
1. The Constitution, Article I, Secs. 8 & 9. Lawler pp. 365-66. Amendment X,
in Lawler, p. 374.
2. The distinction between "federal" and "national." Federalist Papers #39 in Lawler pp.46-49. Important terms: "the federal government", "the national government," "the general government," "sovereignty," "division of sovereignty".
3. DA, pp.62-63; What does Tocqueville think is the advantage of the
federal system for democracy? pp. 58-63 & 246, note 1.
4. Important terms: decentralization, federalism, federal government,
E. Religion as a political institution.
1. DA, p. 292 (bottom).
3. George Washington, "Farewell Address" (1796) in Lawler pp. 43-44.
"Thanksgiving Proclamation" (1789) in RP p. 93-94.
10/28 PAPERS DUE WHICH REQUIRED REVISION
Clarification of matters for the exam next class.
E. Religion as a political institution continued.
DA, (1833) pp. 46-47; 287-290; 290-94; 294-301; 442-44.
11/2 EXAM (In class, short answer, definitions of key vocabulary terms and who said what.
III. Persistent questions about the meaning of liberty and equality in American democracy.
A. Religion as political problem.
1. Thomas Jefferson, "A Bill for Establishing Religious Freedom," (1786) in RP
2. Thomas Jefferson, Letter "To Nehemiah Dodge and Others, A Committee of
3. Thomas Jefferson, First Inaugural Address (1801); Second Inaugural Address
(1805) in RP pp. 3-11.
4. Justice Hugo Black, Everson v. Board of Education (1947) in RP pp. 99-104.
5. Ronald Reagan, "Remarks at an Ecumenical Prayers Breakfast," August 23, 1984
in RP pp. 105-108.
6. What national holiday is celebrated on 11/11? Who knows what the three 11's on
this day refer to?
B. Women and Democracy in
1. Tocqueville's view of women's equality and its consequences for democracy. DA pp. 287, 291, 591, 590-92, 594-600; 600-603.
2. A contemporary view of women's equality and its relation to democracy.
"Change: From What To What" Keynote speech by Barbara Jordan to the
Democratic National Convention, July 1992 in RP pp. 108-110.
C. Citizenship: What makes one an American? Proposition 187 and the recent immigration debate.
1. Being born here or being naturalized.
Amendment, Lawler p. 375-76.
2. Dedication to the proposition that all men are created equal.
Lincoln, Reply to Douglas at
b. Stephen A. Douglas, Speech from the fifth
7, 1858 in RP pp. 113-116.
c. Abraham Lincoln, Reply to Douglas at
d. Frederick Douglass, "The Meaning of July Fourth for the Negro," July 5, 1852,
in RP pp. 14-16, 22-24; “Speech on the Dred Scott Decision” May 11, 1857,
pp. 131- 136.
e. Dred Scott vs.
Justice Taney, in RP pp. 121-128.
D.Affirmative Action: Should constitutional rights belong to individuals
or to groups?
1. Robert Goldwin, "Why Blacks, Women, and Jews are not mentioned in
the Constitution," (1987) in RP 76-85.
2. President Bill Clinton, “Mend It Don’t End It” (1995) in RP 163-168.
3. Ward Connerly, “With
4. Rep. J. C. Watts (2000) in RP, 173.
11/25 Thanksgiving Holiday. Be thankful.
E. Law-abidingness: Should I obey the law?
1. Remember the Declaration of
the right of revolution successfully require law-abidingness? Or is lawlessness
built into the foundational principles of American political life?
2.What is law abidingness?
Is disagreement with the Supreme Court disobedience to the law?
Frederick Douglass, "The Dred Scott Decision" May 11, 1857, in RP p. 131.
3. What is the Thanksgiving holiday for?
a. George Washington, “Thanksgiving Proclamation” (1789), RP, 93-94.
b. James Madison, “[Repentance and Thanksgiving] Proclamation,”
November 16, 1814, RP, 94-95.
c. Abraham Lincoln, “Proclamation of Thanksgiving” (1863), RP, 95-96.
5.Why do/should we obey the law?
a. Because it is self-imposed. DA, pp. 240-241.
b. Out of public spirit. Abraham Lincoln, "The Perpetuation of Our
Political Institutions," (1838)in RP pp. 137-142.
c. Out of enlightened self-interest. DA, pp. 235-37.
6.Civil Disobedience: Is law abidingness sometimes neither good nor a duty?
King, Jr., "Letter from the
12/7 (Tuesday) Final Exam. 12:00-1:50 pm. ESSAY & SHORT ANSWERS [including definitions of key vocabulary terms and who said what]
POLICIES AND EXPECTATIONS
1. Classroom behavior. Courtesy and regard for one another should guide classroom behavior. Students are expected to be in class when class begins. Please do not come late to class. Lateness is inconsiderate and disruptive. The instructor will be on time. Please pay him the same courtesy. If it becomes necessary, students who come late may be barred from class. Occasional lapses can happen to anyone and will be overlooked presuming an explanation and apology presented after class. Please consult with him if a schedule problem effects your ability to meet this requirement. In general, if you get to class late, it is more considerate and less disruptive if you do not enter the room.
Students are expected to be attentive to the lectures and discussions. Students who sleep, read the newspaper, persistently talk with other students or are otherwise inattentive to the lectures and discussion will be asked to leave the class and will be subject to being administratively dismissed from the course at the instructors request.
2. Attendance. Attendance at each class is both expected and required. Attendance will be taken at most classes after the first few days. Being in attendance is operationally defined as being present when attendance is taken at the beginning of class and remaining until class is dismissed. Students who come to class after attendance has been taken, that is after they have been marked absent, will be considered absent. No distinction is made between excused and unexcused absences. However, absences should be explained in writing on the first class you return. A record of such explanations will be kept and that record could be beneficial at final grading time. Students who have extended absences due to illness should notify the instructor as promptly as possible during the absence and produce a doctors note indicating the nature and duration of the illness. This note should be presented at the first class upon returning. Extended absences are regarded as not fulfilling course requirements and, unless justified with appropriate documentation, will adversely effect the final grade. (See section 7 below.)
3. Texts. Since classes are usually conducted by reading and discussing passages from the assigned readings, it is required that you bring the appropriate readings to each class. To that end, it is required that each student have his or her own copy of each text.
4. Class Preparation. The best way to prepare for each class is to do the readings at least once (some require more than one reading) prior to the first day we begin each unit. You will be much better able to participate in and to grasp the class discussions if you have done so.
5. Good note taking is important to your success in this class. Learn to listen carefully to the arguments made and write them down as best you can. Review your notes after class to see if they make sense. By reviewing them soon after they are taken, sometimes you can remember things that will make sense out of what is confusing. Get together with other students periodically to go over each others notes. If you got 50% of the lecture and your study partners got 50%, perhaps between you will have 75%. What remains unclear can be discussed with the instructor. One of the important suggestions I can make is to be sure to write down the questions asked by other students and my answers. Otherwise, if you write down only my answers, it will be meaningless since you will lack the question to which it is an answer. I frequently use students’ questions as a vehicle to make important points so if you write down their questions, as well as my answers, you will benefit.
6. Class Participation. The proper kind of participation in the class is expected, required and rewarded. Participation means that students demonstrate that they are trying to under stand the arguments being made both in the readings and in the lectures, by asking questions or making comments which show problems with the arguments and by responding to questions which the instructor raises. Some classes will be mainly lecture and discussion. Others will involve reading and discussing passages from the readings. It is important that you understand the sort of participation expected because some students think that merely talking fulfills this expectation. It does not. The kind of talking that does is that which fulfills the purposes of participation which are threefold: 1) to enable students to raise questions concerning the meaning of the lectures which shows that they are following the arguments being made enough to see the difficulties; 2) to show that they have read the texts before coming to class and seen enough to identify things that they do not understand or that seem not to "make sense"; 3) to relate different arguments, passages and insights from both texts and lectures to each other. The kind of participation expected is one which shows that you are trying to understand what the whole picture looks like, what each part looks like, and how the parts fit into that whole.
7. Study Groups. Success in college, at least in demanding courses, is facilitated by the formation and regular meeting of study groups. This class will encourage such formation and will appoint a graduate students to assist those of you who wish to make use of this opportunity. But you must take the initiative and organize the group.
One value of a study group is that you help fill in each others notes (if you got 50% of what was said in class and the others a similar percentage, among you you may have 75%). Another value of a study group is that you discover what you do not quite understand when you try to explain it to each other. A third value is that, by working together, some of you will become friends.
8. Grading. Final course grades are based on all of the required written work, the regularity and quality of class participation and, to a lesser extent, on attendance. There will be several (about 5) short quizzes (which cumulatively equal one exam grade), a 3 pp. paper, a mid term and a final exam (both in class). No percentage of the overall grade is assigned to any of these tests of learning. However, no one can receive a final course grade that is more than one grade higher than the final exam grade. The quizzes are over the reading and lectures for the preceding week. The exams require demonstration of the ability to understand the arguments studied and the ability to state and evaluate them in good standard English. Ability to use English with precision and care reflects the capacity to think and communicate clearly and will accordingly improve your examination grade. And conversely. Learn key vocabulary terms.
In determining the final course grade, students with 5 or more absences may have their final grade lowered. Aside from grading consequences which might follow from students being administratively dismissed from the course, the instructor does not give a formal grade or assign a specific percentage of the final grade for class participation. However, he reserves the right to raise a students final grade, if he judges a particular student's participation to have been exceptionally good. Grades are not lowered merely for lack of active class participation.
1. Papers. The paper is due on the date specified. Late papers will be accepted up to 3 days after the due date. However, you should expect them to be docked one letter grade for each day they are late.
2. Make-up quizzes\exams. A make-up quiz or exam will be given only with adequate documentation that the absence was unavoidable. The make-up exams are sufficiently more difficult than the original that prudent people will avoid them where possible.
3. Appointments. The instructor will make every reasonable effort to be available to you. If you cannot come during his scheduled office hours, please call to schedule a mutually convenient appointment. (Both his office number and phone number are at the beginning of the syllabus). Please do not stop by his office without an appointment. If you cannot reach him by phone, leave a message for him to call you on his voice mail or his e-mail. The message should include times when you are likely to be reachable. Please do not call his home.